England face a major dilemma over the all-rounder's role for the opening Test against Australia on Thursday as they decide whether to risk the fitness of Andrew Flintoff just one match after his return from a hernia operation.
The Lancashire vice-captain made his competitive comeback in this week's three-day drawn match with Queensland, scoring three and claiming 2-112 from 26 overs just over a week after being sent to the Academy to complete his rehabilitation from the surgery at the end of last season.
The tourists were delighted with his efforts, particularly as he had been unable to run at full capacity or bowl when he left the squad and flew to Adelaide to receive intensive care, but they have taken their toll on his body.
After delivering 18 overs on the opening day, he was noticeably stiff the day after and struggled to regain the pace England will need in the Ashes.
It is that doubt which may prompt England to instead rely on Craig White, who was added to the squad as cover for Flintoff, and put the Yorkshire all-rounder in line for his first Test appearance since suffering an abdominal strain during the draw against India at Trent Bridge last August.
"That will be the main debate in the selection over the next few days," admitted captain Nasser Hussain today.
"Andrew has nothing to prove in our team. He has performed and the only thing he has to prove is whether he can do it two or three days running because of his body now and whether we take that gamble.
"The first day of this week's game he was fine, but on the second day he was stiff and I don't know if he can do that over five days of intense Test match cricket if he's not 100 per cent fit."
Flintoff has been the subject of some scrutiny by the Australian media, who have questioned his selection for the tour squad at all after analysing his Test statistics with a batting average of 19.48 and a bowling record of 47.15.
But Hussain is fiercely protective of his major all-rounder and stressed: "Statistics aren't everything.
"As captain there are certain players you like having in your side and there are certain players with the potential of doing things that other players can't.
"There are certain players that when the ball is 70 overs old and other people are hiding will hold their hands up and do the tough yards for you. Andrew Flintoff is one of those people.
"He's got to improve those statistics definitely, but anyone who has watched us and watched Freddie progress over the last year or so will have seen him do certain things that other people in England can't do."
Comments: Our rules
We want our comments to be a lively and valuable part of our community - a place where readers can debate and engage with the most important local issues. The ability to comment on our stories is a privilege, not a right, however, and that privilege may be withdrawn if it is abused or misused.
Please report any comments that break our rules.
Read the rules hereComments are closed on this article